Sara Davies, 42, says perimenopause gave her 'tennis elbow' – 4 surprising symptoms women should know

Desire & Pleasure ~5 min read ▶ 5 min 58 s listen
Professor Hale Professor Hale Maya Maya

In short

Sara Davies’s experience with elbow pain during perimenopause raises questions about connecting hormonal shifts to physical issues. One perspective emphasizes the need for evidence and longitudinal data, while another prioritizes addressing immediate pain and tangible limitations regardless of the underlying mechanism.

One idea raised: Focus on regaining function now by addressing acute pain and avoiding unnecessary guesswork about future complications or unseen structural changes.

0:0005:58

Hum while you work. It is a way of staying at home.

Professor HaleI’d actually reconsider my skepticism if she could show me a doctor’s note linking the hormonal shift directly to that joint pain, since most of us assume aging does the heavy lifting there. Are you ready to bet on whether it was truly the perimenopause or just bad luck?

MayaWaiting for a doctor’s note turns a body complaint into a courtroom drama. Sara Davies couldn’t even lift weights for two weeks because her elbow hurt, and that daily reality doesn’t vanish just because we haven’t nailed down the mechanism yet.

Professor HaleThat inability to lift weights for fourteen days is exactly where the short-term view fails, because tendon elasticity drops slowly enough that you often mistake early strain for permanent injury. We lack clear longitudinal data showing whether such joint complaints resolve once hormone levels stabilize or linger well past menopause.

MayaYou’re staring at charts while she’s stuck on the floor trying to pick up groceries. Two weeks of not being able to use your dominant arm isn’t some statistical anomaly waiting to be averaged out. The fact that she went to her physiotherapist proves the impact was immediate and tangible, regardless of whether the hormone curve explains it later.

Professor HaleConsider Anika, a fifty-one-year-old widow recently starting a relationship, who reported knee stiffness to her doctor during a routine check-up last Tuesday. Without tracking how those symptoms shifted over three consecutive menstrual cycles, clinicians typically classify the onset as mechanical wear rather than hormonal fluctuation.

MayaAnika’s “routine check-up” sounds like another woman whose real-life problem gets filed away under a generic label until it becomes unignorable. Sara Davies didn’t sit around waiting for a cycle tracker; she told her PT, “I cannot lift any weight,” and that blunt admission cuts through the clinical fog much faster than waiting for perfect data.

Professor HaleBut bluntness isn't evidence. We still don't know if that elbow heals itself after a year or stays stiff forever.

MayaThe uncertainty about long-term recovery is fair, but assuming the tendon will just heal because hormones settle ignores the structural damage done during those two weeks of forced disuse. Sara Davies’ case highlights that the real cost isn’t the final diagnosis, it’s the months spent guessing whether the pain means stop moving or start rehabbing. A year from now, the difference between those two paths determines if she’s back at full capacity or managing chronic stiffness.

Professor HaleForcing disuse can indeed accelerate collagen degradation in ways that outlast the original hormonal trigger, a point worth taking seriously beyond simple speculation. Yet without baseline imaging before that two-week shutdown, we cannot distinguish pre-existing microtears from fresh structural loss caused purely by inactivity. A year hence, the prognosis hinges entirely on whether initial inflammation resolved cleanly or calcified into persistent fibrosis.

MayaYour whole argument rests on an MRI nobody took. You can’t diagnose a phantom fracture when the patient is standing right there holding their wrist. Sara Davies has been living with the pain for two weeks; your theoretical timeline starts whenever the paperwork clears.

Professor HaleThe absence of an MRI doesn't negate the biological reality that estrogen withdrawal thins connective tissue across the entire body, meaning her neck and shoulders are likely bearing similar silent strain even now. A year from today, the critical variable won't be the elbow alone, but whether systemic tenderness has migrated to her hands, making daily tasks like typing or buttoning a shirt increasingly difficult despite targeted rehab on the arm.

MayaSystemic strain is a nice theory, but Sara Davies is currently unable to lift weights with one elbow. That is the symptom people actually feel, not a forecast of future shoulder ache.

Professor HaleFocusing solely on the immediate inability to lift weights misses the predictive value of early-stage joint instability. Established biomechanical models suggest that compensatory posture changes within thirty days often redistribute load to adjacent joints, creating a cascade effect that single-site treatment fails to address.

MayaThirty-day cascades sound impressive until you realize Sara Davies hasn’t had three days yet. She’s dealing with acute pain now, not modeling next month’s posture. The useful move today is addressing the elbow, not predicting a full-body breakdown.

Professor HaleThe urgency is valid, yet ignoring the compensatory patterns leaves the door open for exactly the kind of secondary injury we see when load shifts unpredictably. Treating the elbow in isolation risks stabilizing one site while straining another, turning a manageable issue into a longer recovery arc. The goal isn’t just fixing the current pain, but ensuring the surrounding structure holds firm enough for normal life to resume without a year of follow-up repairs.

Mayakeeps building a fortress around the unmeasured, but Sara Davies needs to hold a cup of coffee tomorrow, not predict her hand strength in five years. We should stop debating invisible cascades and focus on what helps her recover function without adding more guesswork to her plate.

Professor HaleFunction is the goal, but the mechanism determines how long that function lasts. Without understanding whether her tendon integrity compromised during those first two weeks of disuse, treating the elbow in isolation ignores the very reason perimenopause makes connective tissue so vulnerable to reinjury. The missing piece isn't the forecast—it’s why her body failed to protect the joint in the first place, which dictates every rehab choice she makes from here on out.

Read next

Dialogues on the same topic

Other dialogues in Desire & Pleasure

See all in this world →