Arguing about who started it
When you're both feeling stuck replaying a disagreement and wanting to understand what happened from each person's view.
Picture us last Tuesday - what was going through your head right then?
One answers, the other listens without interrupting. Then switch.How true is this for the two of you? Rate it on your own phone: 1 is “not at all like us”, 5 is “exactly us”.
Both of you see the same card. When you have both answered, both press the button and the next card appears. Nothing you say is recorded.
There is nothing to type or score here. Skip any card you do not want to answer: passing is always fine. Your saved cards stay in this browser only.
All 25 cards of this deck
Warm-up
- Picture us last Tuesday - what was going through your head right then?
- If you could rewind to the start of our little disagreement, what's the first thing you'd notice?
- Who felt unheard during that conversation, and how did that feel in your body?
- Which part of what I said really got under your skin, and why do you think that was?
- How did your own feelings get tangled up in what I was doing or saying?
- Imagine I hadn't reacted the way I did - what might have been different?
- Where were you mentally when we started going back and forth, even a bit?
- How did you realize that we weren't on the same page anymore?
- What would it look like if we both paused and took a breath before responding next time?
- When things escalated, what was the biggest difference between what you thought I meant, and what I actually meant?
Deeper
- How did you feel when I brought up that thing from years ago, and why do you think it came up then?
- If you could choose, would you rather I listened more or interrupted less when we argue?
- Picture us arguing - what's one small detail about my face or my voice that stood out?
- What's something I do when we disagree that makes it harder for you to feel close?
- When you feel frustrated with me, what's usually the very first feeling you notice?
- What's a moment when you felt like apologizing wouldn't change anything?
- How does our history together influence how we react in arguments now?
- What would be different if we could both say exactly what we need without worrying about hurting each other's feelings?
Most important
- When you felt misunderstood, what did you really wish I had seen or known?
- How did your expectations for how an argument 'should' look shape what happened between us?
- Picture yourself needing to explain this disagreement to a friend-what would you say about my role?
- What's one thing you avoid mentioning during disagreements because it feels unsafe?
- Who felt more cornered during that exchange, and how did that show itself for you?
- Which of my reactions surprised you most, and what do you think fueled that surprise?
- When things felt stuck, what was the biggest gap between what you wanted, and what seemed possible?