Rules for a fair argument

When disagreements arise during a cozy evening discussing weekend plans, this collection of questions aids in establishing respectful communication boundaries and ensuring both voices are valued.

Imagine we're arguing over which movie to watch - who usually gets their way?

One answers, the other listens without interrupting. Then switch.

💌 Send as a card

There is nothing to type or score here. Skip any card you do not want to answer: passing is always fine. Your saved cards stay in this browser only.

All 27 cards of this deck

Warm-up

  1. Imagine we're arguing over which movie to watch - who usually gets their way?
  2. Tell me about a time you felt truly heard during a disagreement with me.
  3. Which feels easier for you: starting a difficult conversation or letting it simmer?
  4. Picture us disagreeing about something small, like dinner plans - what's your ideal pause word?
  5. How do you notice when I'm interrupting you, even unintentionally, while we talk?
  6. When you need a moment to process during an argument, where do you go mentally?
  7. Who decides when an argument is 'over' for you - is it a feeling or a signal?
  8. How could we make sure we both feel okay after an argument, beyond just a hug?
  9. What's one small rule we could agree on now that would make disagreements kinder?
  10. If we had to pick one: a quick hug or a concrete plan afterward-which feels better?

Deeper

  1. Picture us arguing about something important - what does your body do then?
  2. Tell me about a time you wished I'd understood your feelings better during a fight.
  3. How did you learn to handle disagreements growing up, and how does that show up now?
  4. What's one thing I do that makes it harder for you to express yourself calmly?
  5. Imagine you're frustrated but can't say exactly why - how do I help you find those words?
  6. Which feels safer: expressing vulnerability during an argument, or holding back?
  7. How do you know when a disagreement has become truly unfair, from your point of view?
  8. Tell me about a small memory of a time you felt powerless in a disagreement, anywhere.
  9. What would you want me to say if I knew you were struggling to keep calm?

Most important

  1. Imagine we're revisiting a past argument - what's one thing you wish we'd handled differently?
  2. Tell me about a time you felt silenced or dismissed - not necessarily by me, anyone.
  3. How do you experience physical tension when you sense an argument escalating between us?
  4. Which feels more comforting after a disagreement: space to process alone, or immediate closeness?
  5. Picture us arguing about finances - what's one worry you have about bringing that up?
  6. What would you need from me to feel safe enough to admit you might be wrong?
  7. If we could redesign our arguing style completely, what's one essential element we'd include?
  8. How does your idea of a 'fair' argument differ from what you think mine looks like?

More decks

All decks