No, it is about consent: A response to the Sundial’s defense of rape culture

Psychology ~3 min read ▶ 4 min listen
Professor Hale Professor Hale Maya Maya

In short

Debate around a news headline regarding consent focuses on responsibility after a violation occurs. One perspective emphasizes how trauma can cause paralysis and memory fragmentation, suggesting private conversations to clarify events, while another highlights the immediate impact of violation and the shortcomings of relying on safe spaces within a legal system. It centers on protecting the accuracy of the record.

One idea raised: Document the sequence of events, clearly identifying instances where consent wasn't given, to ensure an accurate account.

0:0004:16

A good listener has no need to be clever.

Lines worth sharing

Each one is a ready picture: share the link and it appears as a card in the feed, or save the image. Cards marked ▶ Video also come as a short clip with music: tap to watch, then save or share it.

Helps when: I find it hard to trust · I can't say no

Professor HaleI think we’ve spent enough energy debating the label when the core issue was always about permission. The argument isn't whether something fits a definition, it’s whether anyone actually said yes. Maya, if the defense rests on claiming there’s no such thing as a violation without intent, how does that leave room for basic accountability?

MayaYour “basic accountability” framing misses how people actually freeze up in the heat of the moment. When you define consent solely by the absence of force, you’re telling victims they failed to be physically restrained enough to trigger the legal alarm. That puts the burden of proving their right to safety squarely on the victim’s body rather than the perpetrator’s actions.

Professor HaleBefore anything happens, people are scanning for signals like checking a weather forecast—looking for rain or sun while assuming the ground stays solid. But if we tell someone they’re responsible for preventing a disaster because they didn’t scream loud enough, we’re asking them to predict violence based on silence.

MayaPeople fear becoming complicit by staying silent, which turns self-preservation into a moral failing. They dread the aftermath where their hesitation gets dissected as evidence of willingness rather than trauma. This dynamic forces survivors to perform certainty under scrutiny.

Professor HaleConsider the moment after the encounter ends, when the phone screen lights up with a text asking "Are you okay?" but the survivor cannot type back because their hands won't stop shaking. In the literature on post-traumatic stress, we see this paralysis described repeatedly—the body refuses to engage even though the immediate threat has passed. The next day brings the harder task of explaining why silence wasn't consent, often in front of people who expect a clean narrative. That expectation ignores how the brain fragments memory during high-stakes moments, leaving gaps that get misread as ambiguity. What matters here is recognizing that the inability to speak clearly afterward doesn't negate the prior lack of permission; it just complicates the proof.

MayaYou’re romanticizing the pause. The first ten seconds aren’t about trembling hands; they’re about the victim staring at their own clothes, realizing the person who violated them is still breathing in the next room. No words are exchanged. Just the sickening weight of knowing the law will soon ask why they didn’t fight back.

Professor HalePeople wait for permission to feel afraid, assuming shock means they're overreacting to a misunderstanding.

MayaNo. You made their pain sound manageable.

Professor HaleAcknowledging that my phrasing minimized the immediate terror is important. We must shift the focus to the subsequent dialogue, ensuring it occurs in a private, low-pressure setting rather than demanding a public statement. Accountability requires a safe space for the truth to emerge before external pressure distorts it further.

MayaSafe spaces don't fix broken laws.

Professor HaleA good outcome isn’t a grand confession, but two people sitting down without witnesses and saying exactly what happened, step by step. The accuser names the act plainly, and the accused hears it without interrupting to defend their intent. That exchange sets the record straight for anyone who might hear the story later, removing the fog around whether permission was asked for and granted.

MayaIf the accused starts defending their intent instead of listening, walk out and call a trusted friend immediately. Do not try to finish the argument yourself while still in that room. Let a third party handle the follow-up so the details stay intact.

Professor HaleWalking away protects the facts, but tomorrow morning changes everything once the adrenaline fades. That is when you sit down with someone you trust and write down the timeline, specifically noting where consent was missing, so the record stands firm regardless of what happens legally. Your job right now is not to win a single argument, but to ensure the truth survives contact with disbelief.

MayaWriting it down helps you remember, but it doesn't change who decides if the law applies. The system asks for a perfect narrative because that makes processing cheap for everyone else involved. Stop expecting the paperwork to save you from the next hearing.

Read next

Dialogues on the same topic

If this one stuck with you

A different subject, but the same kind of feeling

Other dialogues in Psychology

See all in this world →