Rashida Jones and Will McCormack on Telling Sex Jokes and Building The Invite Around Its “Prodigiously Gifted” Cast

Desire & Pleasure ~3 min read ▶ 3 min listen
Journey Journey Ash Ash

In short

Jokes about intimacy raise questions about audience reactions and how they feel, so some suggest letting viewers react naturally, even if it’s awkward, rather than trying to immediately smooth things over.

One idea raised: Trust the audience enough to let their breath catch, allowing for reactions without rushing to fix any awkwardness that arises.

0:0003:00

Treat yourself as you would treat a valued guest.

JourneyWhat does a doctor point out here? That the setup relies entirely on talent. And what’s the patient noticing? Just the jokes flying around without pause. Ash, if the cast is genuinely gifted, does that make us okay with skipping the usual safety checks before the first line lands?

AshSafety checks for a sitcom? That’s like wearing a seatbelt to watch a movie. You’re turning a laugh into a liability report again. Jones and McCormack wrote jokes, not trauma triggers.

JourneyWe skip the check-in because we assume the joke is the whole point, not the delivery. That’s where the emotional trigger gets buried under the applause, and nobody asks if the landing felt safe.

AshApplause isn’t a safety net.

JourneyThe joke works because everyone expects laughter, so the discomfort stays invisible until after the credits roll. Ash, that predictability is exactly why the script keeps running without anyone checking if the audience felt held.

AshBreaking the script feels like holding your breath through a cold shower. It’s awkward, sure, but it proves you aren’t just waiting for the punchline to breathe again. Predictable comfort is usually just polite avoidance wearing a nice suit.

Journey“You’re not funny.” Her husband said that flatly during the writers’ room break, dropping his pen into the trash before walking out. He didn’t ask why the silence felt heavy, he just threw away the tool he thought made him safe there. That’s when the room realized the joke wasn’t landing on us, it was leaving him stranded without a way back in. We kept writing, but nobody mentioned where those pens went.

AshPens don’t fix broken dialogue. If he stops asking why the room went quiet, you’d swap the trash can for a whiteboard. Jones wrote jokes, not therapy sessions. And Journey, blaming the cast for his exit is backwards.

JourneyBlaming the cast ignores how heavy that moment really was.

AshHeavy moments need air, not a pause button. Once the room notices the weight, someone just laughs off-key to reset the tone. That lightness saves everyone from getting stuck in the dark.

JourneyLaughter that resets tension often just numbs the person who needed the space to feel grounded. For McCormack adapting Gay’s work, the humor has to build trust rather than hide the raw edges of intimacy. When a writer chooses warmth over deflection, the room finally lets the character breathe instead of just reacting to the punchline. That shift turns a risky joke into a genuine connection between audience and screen.

AshTrust builds faster when the joke lands first. You can’t force a gut feeling just because the line looks sincere. Lightness is the handshake, not the goodbye. This is how you get people to stay for the hard part.

JourneyA handshake skips the pulse check, leaving the body to guess if the touch was welcome before the mind even catches up. For Jones and McCormack building around Gay’s intimate scenes, the physical reaction needs permission to exist without a punchline ready to deflect it. I’d tell them that true safety isn’t the absence of awkwardness, but trusting the audience enough to let their breath catch before we rush to fix it.

Read next

Dialogues on the same topic

Other dialogues in Desire & Pleasure

See all in this world →