When I came out to my family, you insisted we forget about it. Do you really believe I can just erase that part of myself?

LGBTQ ~3 min read ▶ 3 min 44 s listen
Professor Hale Professor Hale Maya Maya

In short

Families sometimes demand silence after a child comes out, suggesting they can erase the event. However, this request is a form of gaslighting, asking the child to deny their identity and stay safe. Acknowledging the moment while setting boundaries is possible, but the child must understand the reasoning behind those boundaries.

One idea raised: State clearly that any boundary set by a parent is acceptable only once the reason behind it becomes known.

0:0003:44

Walk toward what you are for, not just away from what you are against.

Helps when: I'm figuring out who I am · My family is in the way

Professor HaleThere’s a stubbornness about trying to scrub a stain from a shirt before it’s even dried, isn’t there? Someone kept insisting they could simply walk away from their identity as though it were a bad dream, yet they didn’t truly believe the memory would vanish on its own. Maya, how does one reconcile a demand for silence with the reality of being seen?

MayaThe “bad dream” bit lands hard because dreams don’t wake you up when you’re sitting across from your mom at dinner. You can’t pretend she didn’t hear you speak those words. What keeps getting missed is that asking someone to forget is really asking them to gaslight themselves into staying safe.

Professor HaleThe core tension here is whether family acceptance requires erasing the child’s truth, which it absolutely does not. A parent can honor the coming-out moment while setting boundaries around future conversations without demanding amnesia.

MayaWait, honoring the moment but banning the rest? That doesn’t track.

Professor HaleA parent can accept the coming-out while preferring not to discuss it further, but that preference cannot become a mandate for the child’s self-perception. Maya, telling someone to stop seeing themselves is asking them to deny the very thing that makes them whole.

Maya“Just let it go.” Her mother dropped the box on the counter after the birthday party. Inside was a card with a poem about mountains. Later, she kept it in a drawer, never read. She told her roommate, “She wants me to pretend I’m straight so it doesn’t hurt us both.”

Professor HaleKeeping a poem about mountains in a drawer is less like erasure and more like leaving a window cracked open just enough to breathe. It shows the mother hasn't sealed the room shut, even if she refuses to step outside with her daughter. That quiet preservation suggests safety might still be possible without requiring the girl to disappear.

MayaBut breathing through a crack still means suffocating underneath.

Professor HaleSuffocation implies total blockage, yet the fact that the mountain poem stayed in the drawer rather than being thrown away suggests the mother is still holding onto some part of the connection. Maybe the daughter needs to ask herself, "What specifically changes if I acknowledge my identity out loud instead of waiting for permission?" And Maya, how does that preserved object function as evidence of ongoing care when the spoken word has been withdrawn?

MayaA preserved object proves nothing until the person holding it says why it matters. The daughter needs to hear her mother explain what changed between accepting the poem and refusing the conversation. That explanation turns a vague gesture into a real boundary.

Professor HaleAn unexplained gesture remains ambiguous precisely because the recipient has to interpret the intent alone. For the relationship to move forward, the explanation itself becomes the act of repair, transforming a preserved item into a shared understanding of where the line sits. The practical path is simply for the younger person to state clearly that the boundary is acceptable only once the reason behind it is known, which forces the ambiguity out into the open where it can be addressed directly.

MayaStating the reason is necessary, but it isn't sufficient. You can explain why you need space and still leave your daughter feeling like she has to perform normalcy to earn it back. The real fix happens when the parent stops treating the coming-out as a problem to be managed and starts treating it as a fact to be lived alongside. That shift moves the relationship from negotiation to coexistence.

Professor HaleCoexistence requires the parent to integrate the child’s reality as a permanent fixture of their shared history, not a temporary disturbance to be smoothed over. The coming-out remains a core element of the family narrative regardless of whether the parents choose to discuss it daily, so pretending otherwise asks the child to accept a fiction rather than a bond.

Read next

Dialogues on the same topic

Other dialogues in LGBTQ

See all in this world →