You came out to your father six weeks ago and they asked you not to mention it at your college friend group from a religious school — is keeping the peace worth going back into hiding for one room?
In short
A person grapples with their father's request to keep their recent coming out private from their religious school friends. The hosts debate whether respecting this boundary is worth sacrificing authenticity and facing potential rejection, acknowledging the emotional toll of handling such situations. They suggest observing how long the request lasts.
One idea raised: Giving someone time to adjust to big news can be worthwhile, but don't let it cost you your sense of self.
A shared history is a beautiful thing.
Lines worth sharing
Each one is a ready picture: share the link and it appears as a card in the feed, or save the image. Cards marked ▶ Video also come as a short clip with music: tap to watch, then save or share it.
Helps when: I'm figuring out who I am · My family is in the way
DannyHey, I've got something worth chewing on: You came out to your father six weeks ago and they asked you not to mention it at your college friend group from a religious school — is keeping the peace worth going back into hiding for one room. What's your gut say?
StephSix weeks isn't enough time for that ask to sink in, but pretending you didn't hear it is worse than staying quiet. When I kept my distance from that church crowd for years, it wasn't for their sake, it was because every single lie cost me a piece of myself. Your dad asking for silence in one specific room doesn't mean you owe everyone there a secret identity.
DannyWait, "one specific room" makes it sound easy, but those friends sit in the same dining hall, take the same classes, and share the same chapel every Sunday morning. You're telling me you can walk through a crowded quad without anyone noticing you're holding a grudge against your own existence? That's not keeping peace, that's just performing a very convincing funeral for yourself in front of people who think they love you.
StephYou’re making it sound like you have to announce every single day, when really you just don’t owe them a performance. I sat in that exact kind of dining hall for four years, and I learned that the only thing that actually shrank was my tolerance for being watched, not my life. Stop trying to convince me it’s impossible; you’re just mad that he made you feel small.
DannyPicture a guy who finally tells his best friend he’s gay after two years of circling the drain, only to find out the friend keeps “forgetting” to use his pronouns in front of the whole team. You don’t owe that friend a second chance at normalcy just because he’s been polite since Tuesday; sometimes the quietest part of your life is exactly where the biggest mess lives.
StephYou’re comparing a deliberate slur to a request for privacy, and that’s where your argument falls apart. Imagine a coworker who asks you not to post about their divorce at work so they can focus on the job—you’d respect that boundary even if it meant missing out on office gossip, right? Silence in one context isn’t erasure; it’s just choosing where to spend your energy, and you’ve spent plenty talking to us while ignoring that simple trade-off.
DannyThe divorce example fails because nobody asks coworkers to erase their entire soul for nine hours a day. Choosing where to spend energy sounds noble until the chosen spot is the only place you were allowed to be real.
Stephadmits he sees the trap clearly now—the moment the only safe harbor gets fenced off, it stops feeling like safety and starts feeling like exile. But you’re still skipping over how temporary this actually needs to be; I survived three semesters at that religious college by picking which battles mattered, not by declaring war in the cafeteria. Six weeks is long enough to test whether he means it as a permanent cage or just a rough patch while everyone adjusts.
DannyThree semesters is a long time to call a rough patch, but I’ll grant you that waiting six weeks does sort of prove he isn’t just panicking in the moment. Still, nobody told him how much the chapel smells like old wood and incense, which is exactly why walking past it feels like swallowing a stone every single morning.
StephComparing a smell to a stone is dramatic, but I remember standing in that exact chapel for four years and mostly wondering if the incense was going to set off the fire alarm before graduation. You are letting the atmosphere do the arguing for you, which is a lot easier than deciding if this is actually a permanent ban or just him needing a minute to process what he heard.
DannyYour fire alarm joke misses that the real problem is the guy sitting three rows back who suddenly can't look you in the eye during prayer. He’s not adjusting to news; he’s actively unlearning a friendship he thought existed, and you want me to believe that’s just atmosphere? That’s not processing, that’s slow-motion rejection happening in real time under your nose.
StephCalling it "slow-motion" makes it sound inevitable, but I watched guys go from stiff silence to awkward nods within a month. Give the eye contact a few more weeks before you declare the whole friendship dead.
DannyA nod doesn’t fix the fact that he’s quietly editing our history to make himself comfortable. If the friendship requires amnesia to survive, it wasn’t really there to begin with.
StephI sat through two years of friends quietly rewriting shared memories after my coming-out, and none of them stopped showing up at my door when things got bad. Amnesia implies abandonment, but staying reachable while keeping quiet says more about endurance than betrayal.
DannyEndurance without truth isn’t loyalty; it’s just holding your breath underwater hoping the surface comes first. You kept the door open because you could handle the weight of being half-seen, but most people don’t have that kind of reserve. One room shouldn’t cost them their whole sense of self.
StephHolding your breath works fine until you actually need air, and I spent two years proving that point without losing anyone worth keeping. The father asking for a pause isn’t erasing who you are; he’s buying time so the rest of your life doesn’t collapse around one uncomfortable room. Don’t mistake his hesitation for a verdict on your identity.
DannyBuying time sounds reasonable until you realize the clock is ticking inside your own head, counting down the seconds until you stop believing you exist outside that chapel. I’d rather face the awkward silence now than spend another semester guessing if my friend even knows who I am anymore. Just because he’s taking his time doesn’t mean the rest of us should hold our breath for him.
Read next
Dialogues on the same topic
You lost most of your college friends from your college friend group from a religious school the moment you came out — was that grief for people you actually knew, or for a version of them you'd invented?
Coming out from a religious background can question past friendships with religious school peers, bringing grief and loss of belonging.
Also about: college · religious
You haven't told your devoutly religious mother you're marrying your fiancé because you know exactly how your college friend group from a religious school would react — is protecting the wedding day worth the silence leading up to it?
Considering a joyous LGBTQ wedding, carefully weigh sharing details with your mother and her religious friends to protect your peace.
Also about: religious · college
You came out to your mother nine years ago and they asked you not to mention it at your college friend group from a religious school — is keeping the peace worth going back into hiding for one room?
Handling coming out to religious friends can be tough, especially when family asks for secrecy. Prioritize honesty by writing down your thoughts and sharing.
Also about: religious · college
You've stayed closeted at your college friend group from a religious school for five months out of fear for your safety or your job — is staying silent self-preservation, or is it a cost nobody should have to calculate?
Concealing your background in college—like delaying disclosure for job security—can be protective or harmful, embrace uncertainty instead.
Also about: religious · college
If this one stuck with you
A different subject, but the same kind of feeling
You've been faking that sex doesn't hurt for three weeks because you don't want to disappoint your partner — whose health matters more in that trade, yours or the relationship's comfort?
Experiencing sexual pain impacts both partners; prioritizing comfort can cause harm. Schedule an ultrasound for weeks of pelvic pain instead of ignoring it.
Your girlfriend mocked a fantasy you shared in a vulnerable moment, more times than you can count, and you've never brought up another one since — how much of your inner life did that one comment cost you?
Mocking comments erode relationship trust, causing vulnerability. Learn how to proactively ask your partner about their preferred conversation style.
You found out your wife told her father your relationship was "basically over" fifteen months before ever saying a word like that to you — who deserved to hear that first?
Confiding relationship doubts to others can cause deep betrayal; address difficult feelings directly with your partner instead of involving outsiders.
You've been the funniest person in every room for twenty years and no one has ever seen you sad — is the joke your gift, or the lock on your door?
Comedy masking sadness can prevent genuine connection; consistently being funny might hide struggles. Checking in reveals needs laughter doesn't fulfill.
Other dialogues in LGBTQ
The actor behind GTA’s first nonbinary character on why the milestone matters: 'We are a part of everyday society'
Players readily trusting virtual worlds, like those in games such as GTA 6, suggests growing acceptance of LGBTQ representation.
You brought up my dad at dinner tonight - something you almost never do. Is it time to accept that our shared history will always shape how you see pride?
Addressing family history’s impact on LGBTQ pride, like a parent’s influence over dinner, requires acknowledging underlying anxieties for open discussion.
Attitude Uncut: The New Masculinity Issue out now on Apple News+ and Attitude app – take a look inside the issue
Attitude magazine redefines masculinity with diverse figures, but does it truly go deeper, revealing genuine confidence and tenderness.
Who was the first trans Bond girl? Hunter Schafer speculation puts Caroline Cossey back in the spotlight
Proactively sharing stories, like Caroline Cossey's experiences with tabloids, can combat misinformation and shape media coverage for trans actors.
I panicked when you used the wrong pronouns after that conversation about transitioning, and you looked furious. How do I fix that with you now?
Misusing pronouns can harm trust, so address fears, avoid silence, and focus on consistent actions, and apologize sincerely today.
You saw me crying on the balcony last night, and quickly looked away. What does seeing me like this do to what you thought about our chosen family?
Supporting a distressed loved one in your chosen family can feel challenging. Sending a simple weekly text reaffirms your presence and ongoing support.